This article was previously published in Appraisal Today newsletter
in November, 1994 and was written by Ann
O'Rourke. For more information on the newsletter, go to Appraisal
Today Info. It is copyrighted. For reprint permission, Contact
Us. NOTE: An updated version of this article was published in
the April, 2000 issue of Appraisal Today. The limit on estate taxes has changed. It is now over $600,000
and is increasing each year.
Appraisals for Estate and Probate Predicted to Increase
The need for appraisals for estate and probate purposes is expected to increase. Estimates of the billions of dollars to be inherited by baby boomers are regularly featured in newspapers and the financial press. Much of those assets are in real estate. With the recent popularity of living trusts, and sophisticated tax avoidance methods for affluent individuals, appraisals are needed both for tax planning purposes prior to a property owner's death, and for settling an estate after death.
When appraisals are needed
As an overview, a non-exhaustive list of when an appraisal could be needed is:
Who needs the appraisals
Who does the appraisals
If there is no estate tax liability, usually because of the marital deduction or the unified credit, often a letter from a real estate agent is used. However, the executor has to have enough nerve to ask for a 'free' appraisal.
If an audit is anticipated, many attorneys and accountants prefer to use a licensed or certified appraiser, plus possibly a second opinion by another appraiser or a real estate agent. An appraiser with superior credentials and methodology and local experience is preferred as the tax court and circuit courts often look to the best appraisal done by the most competent appraiser rather than "splitting the difference."
In California, probate referees are appointed by the probate court and perform real property appraisals for 1/10 of 1% of the value, for example $300 on a $300,000 home. They are exempted from the appraisal ethical conflicts by state law. See if your state has a similar situation. They also get appraisal work from trusts.
Low vs. high values
Executors often ask that the value be "kept low," presumably to minimize estate taxes. But the tradeoff is a higher tax basis. If the gross value of the estate is well under $600,000 and the beneficiaries plan on keeping the property, a higher value to get a larger stepped up basis may be more advantageous. For example, a property is valued at $300,000, rather than $275,000, and is sold 5 years later for $400,000. The taxable gain would be $100,000 if previously appraised at $300,000 and $125,000 if previously appraised at $275,000.
Many people are unaware of the stepped up basis and are surprised later when they sell the property several years (or more) after inheriting it.
For owner occupied homes there is often justification for a value at the low end. Many are sold "as is," may be subject to probate requirements like overbids in probate court, and need work. There are substantial penalties for significant over- or under-valuations.
Whenever there is a gift, the value needs to be determined.
$10,000 per year can be given to each child as a non-taxable gift. The gifts are usually cash, but can be an undivided interest in real estate. A family limited partnership can be set up to make the $10,000 per year gifts.
If the person can afford it, there is a one-time $600,000 gift exemption that freezes the value of the property for estate tax purposes. It is very useful for property that is expected to appreciate. For example, the person owns two properties: a $600,000 home in a popular upscale neighborhood, and a $600,000 ranch in a remote area. Assuming the home will appreciate more than the ranch, you can use the one-time gift exemption to freeze the taxable value.
Charitable remainder trusts avoid capital gains and give the donor a charitable deduction. They're complicated and only apply to property owned free and clear.
These are a popular method of avoiding probate fees and hassles, but don't help avoid estate taxes. Living trusts were formerly used mostly by the wealthy, but have now filtered down to the middle class, and are becoming more popular.
Typically no appraisal is done when the trust is established. Whether or not an appraisal is needed when the person dies depends on how the trust is set up and what is in it. The typical issue is the stepped up basis if the property is not sold. Of course, that's assuming the real property is transferred into the trust before the person dies (funded).
If a decedent has a fractional interest in real property, typically less than 50% interest, that portion must be valued. The value of the interest is usually less than its pro-rata share. For example, the decedent owns a 10% interest in a shopping center worth $1,000,000. The value of the interest is less than $100,000, as they are very hard to sell, with a limited market.
Determine if the interest is fractional before accepting the assignment. Fractional interests are very difficult to value. Either refer them to someone else or take the time necessary to learn how to appraise them from an appraiser with that type of experience. If you plan on doing much estate or probate work, it's probably worthwhile to learn how to appraise them.
Fractional and partial interests are a 'red flag' to the IRS, so be sure the value is as well supported as possible.
Federal estate (death) taxes
If the fair market value of the gross estate is over $600,000 (one person) (1999 NOTE: this limit increases every year), an estate tax return must be filed. Attorneys we spoke with said this often triggers one or more appraisals for each property, as these returns have a very high audit rate. Improper valuations can have high penalties. In community property states like California, if one spouse dies often no return is filed if the total value of the spousal property is under $1,200,000, although technically a return should be filed.
We couldn't get any statistics on how many executors file estate tax returns, but one tax consultant said only around 2% need to file.
The IRS expects the number of estate tax returns to grow by 7.7 percent annually between 1994 and 2000, according to a recent IRS report.
1992: 70,000 (actual)
1993: 75,000 (estimated)
1995: 87,000 (estimated)
2000: 126,000 (estimated)
Every Federal estate tax return is hand screened by experienced estate tax examiners to be classified for audit. The overall audit rate is approximately 20 percent for federal estate tax returns, almost 10 times the audit rate for income tax returns.
Tax rates are from a low of 37 percent to a high of 55 percent. A 20 percent penalty applies to overvaluations (trying to get the basis as high as possible) where the correct value or adjusted basis of any property claimed on a return is 200 percent or more of the correct value. An overstatement of 400 percent of the correct value has a 40 percent penalty.
A 20 percent estate tax penalty applies for estate gift tax understated valuations, if the value is 50 percent or less of the correct value. If 25 percent or less of the correct value, a 40 percent penalty applies.
The IRS's examiner's handbook says that they should request copies of appraisals done within five years of the death and copies of listing information on the subject property within three years of the death.
Date of value and retrospective appraisals
The executor can choose either the date of death, or a date six months later for the effective date of valuation (alternative valuation date). Let the executor know which would provide the more appropriate value (higher or lower) if prices are not stable.
Appraisals done as close to the required date as possible are more accurate and reliable than those done sometime later. If challenged by the IRS, a current appraisal is more credible than one done at a later date.
If the property is held in joint tenancy and an estate tax return is not filed, an appraisal may not be done
at the time of the death of the first joint tenant. Later, when the surviving joint tenant (typically the spouse) dies, the estate needs to establish the basis as of the date of the death of the first joint tenant. This may be many years later.
If you're asked to do a retrospective appraisal, be sure you get a high enough fee to justify the time and risk. Your value will be less reliable than a current appraisal and can be more easily challenged by the IRS. Accurate data on the subject, comps, and the market at that time may be difficult to obtain.
Executors and administrators
The executor sometimes needs values to partition an estate. For example, the decedent has two children, one gets the house and the other gets the stocks, but the estate is to be divided equally between them.
Sometimes the beneficiaries can't agree on 'how much they can get' from the property. One of them may not trust real estate agents and think they 'will try to list it low.' The executor gets an appraisal.
If a relative or a private party wants to purchase the property from the estate, the executor will probably want an appraisal as part of his or her fiduciary duty.
You will often be contacted directly by the executor or trustee if the appraisal is of a home for estate tax purposes. Be sure to talk with the attorney or accountant who told them to get the appraisal to find out about the estate's particular tax situation.
Accountants and non-profits
Many accountants are aware of the stepped up basis issues and will try to get a current value even if no estate tax return is filed. You need to persuade them that an appraisal is more credible to the IRS than a letter from a real estate agent or the owner's opinion of value.
Higher net worth persons are more likely to need appraisals for tax planning and filing. Larger CPA firms with high income individuals are a possibility. Ask your accountant who handles that type of client. Enrolled agents (specialize in tax work) are another possibility.
Organizations that administer gift trusts, such as hospitals, colleges, and other non-profit groups, need appraisals. Contact them directly. Many advertise in local newspapers or magazines.
Marketing to attorneys is primarily by referrals, but you can also send brochures and letters. Contact any attorneys you know and tell them you're interested in doing appraisals for estates and trusts. Ask them which attorneys specialize in that market. Get a copy of your local bar association's directory to see who specializes in estate, trusts, and probate.
Should you do this type of work?
Doing appraisals for estate and probate purposes may not give you a lot of work, but does provide an excellent diversification opportunity. Also, sometimes there are muliple properties to appraise/.
Many appraisers don't like to do litigation and/or divorce work because of the hassles and court testimony. Appearing in court is very unlikely for this type of work, unless it's a very complicated and large estate and it ends up in tax court. Even if you do have to testify, it won't be in front of a jury, just a judge.
In the past, many residential appraisers didn't like to do work for one-time non-lender clients. But the market has changed, and non-lender work can keep you going when the lender market is down.
Most of the business is by referral, so you need to get your name well known in the legal, accounting, and real estate communities.
Yellow Page ads can be very effective for this type of work. In your ad put "Estates and Trusts" in big letters. You will get more work.
Referrals are the primary source of business - real estate agents, attorneys, accountants, etc.
Join a local chapter or group of attorneys specializing in this type of work. You will get more work if you are active.
Send mailings to attorneys who specialize in this type of work.
Where to get more information
In this brief article we can only touch on some of the most important points. Being knowledgeable about estate, trust, and tax issues makes your appraisal services more marketable and convincing.
The tax laws and issues are complicated and keep changing. Classes and seminars are available in many communities. Check at your local adult school or college. Some are advertised in local newspapers.
Many books have been written for laypersons on estate planning, probate, and trusts. Check at your local library or book store. Books published by Nolo Press are well written and understandable.
Be sure to find out about the laws in your state. Each state is different. Check at your local library or ask an attorney where to get more information. Some states have inheritance taxes.
Even if you don't get much work, learning about estates and trusts is worthwhile for your own tax planning, and for your elderly family members'.
Thanks to enrolled agent Margaret Crawford and attorney Mary Widenor of Alameda, CA, Michael Yovino-Young, MAI, SRA, Berkeley, CA, and Larry Levy, SRPA, Los Altos Hills, CA.
Copyrighted by Appraisal Today, 2033 Clement Ave., Suite 105, Alameda, CA 94501, phone 510-865-8041, firstname.lastname@example.org